226 Views

Crucial ocean-acidification models come up short

As the oceans’ chemistry is altered by rising levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide, the response of sea-dwellers such as fish, shellfish and corals is a huge unknown that has implications for fisheries and conservationists alike. But the researchers attempting to find an answer are often failing to properly design and report their experiments, according to an analysis of two decades of literature.

Oceans absorb much of the CO2 emitted by human activities such as coal burning. This leads to a variety of chemical changes, such as making waters more acidic, which are referred to as ocean acidification.

The United Nations has warned that ocean acidification could cost the global economy $1 trillion per year by the end of the century, owing to losses in industries such as fisheries and tourism. Oyster fisheries in the United States are estimated to have already lost millions of dollars as a result of poor harvests, which can be partly blamed on ocean acidification.

The past decade has seen accelerated attempts to predict what these changes in pH will mean for the oceans’ denizens – in particular, through experiments that place organisms in water tanks that mimic future ocean-chemistry scenarios.

Yet according to a survey published last month by marine scientist Christopher Cornwall, who studies ocean acidification at the University of Western Australia in Crawley, and ecologist Catriona Hurd of the University of Tasmania in Hobart, Australia, most reports of such laboratory experiments either used inappropriate methods or did not report their methods properly.

Cornwall says that the “overwhelming evidence” from such studies of the negative effects of ocean acidification still stands. For example, more-acidic waters slow the growth and worsen the health of many species that build structures such as shells from calcium carbonate. But the pair’s discovery that many of the experiments are problematic makes it difficult to assess accurately the magnitude of effects of ocean acidification, and to combine results from individual experiments to build overall predictions for how the ecosystem as a whole will behave, he says.

The survey, published in the journal ICES Journal of Marine Science, was based on a search of the Scopus database of research papers. Cornwall and Hurd analyzed 465 studies published between 1993 and 2014 that manipulated seawater chemistry and found that experiments often failed to implement widely accepted measures to ensure quality.

For instance, to ensure robustness, manipulation studies should use multiple arrays of independent ocean-mimicking tanks. And in experiments that compare sea animals under acidified conditions with controls, these tanks should be randomized to remove bias. But the pair found that in several papers, researchers used one main seawater tank to supply multiple, supposedly independent smaller tanks.

ALSO READ  10 Important Health Benefits Of Cucumber

Chemical errors

The researchers also found mistakes in basic chemistry: Some authors simply added acid to a tank and ignored other chemical changes that result from the absorption of CO2, such as increased levels of carbonates. Although the frequency of these chemistry errors has dropped since the 2010 publication of an international “best practice” guide for ocean-acidification experiments, the researchers found no evidence for improvements in the design of tank arrays.

Bayden Russell, an ocean-acidification researcher at the University of Hong Kong who reviewed drafts of the latest paper, has also noticed that some researchers fail to take into account the complexities of ocean acidification when designing their experiments. “It is these complexities that will drive ecosystem responses to ocean acidification,” he says.

Overall, Cornwall and Hurd found that in only 27 cases could they be certain that an appropriate experimental design had been used, and in 278 cases, the design was clearly inappropriate. The remaining studies had insufficient detail on experimental setup – a problem in itself, note the researchers.

The pair present a series of recommendations for well-designed experiments and suggest a checklist of details that should be included in papers to allow replication of experiments, including which chemicals were used to manipulate the seawater chemistry and the configuration of tank arrays.

Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, director of the Global Change Institute at the University of Queensland in St. Lucia, Australia, suggests that researchers also need to take account of natural variations in temperature and CO2 in experimental setups and ensure that experiments that manipulate acidity also simulate the accompanying rise in temperature from global warming, which many do not.

Pressure to publish

Russell thinks that most research groups are now trying to use appropriate designs, but says that there are still problems, which he attributes to a variety of factors.

“Unfortunately, truly rigorous designs are logistically complex and expensive in both setup costs and ongoing maintenance time,” he says. “When superimposed on the increasing pressure to publish rapidly, and in top journals, some researchers or research groups are still attempting to publish what I would consider substandard research.”

Jonathan Havenhand, who works on marine invertebrates at the University of Gothenburg in Sweden and who co-authored the 2010 guide, welcomes the latest paper: “Everybody should know the stuff that’s in Cornwall and Hurd’s paper. It’s good that they wrote it. It’s disappointing that they had to.”

Havenhand suspects the paper will be highly cited. “Whether people are going to be happy to be citing it, I don’t know.”

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Latest Posts

How Kebbi State Government Publicly Disregarded First Wife, Aisha Bagudu As State’s First Lady
Politics
18 views
Politics
18 views

How Kebbi State Government Publicly Disregarded First Wife, Aisha Bagudu As State’s First Lady

MT - April 23, 2018

A mild drama recently occurred on Twitter leading to a public revelation that the popular Aisha Bagudu isn't recognized as first lady.  Recently, one of the national…

Moment Nigerian Singer Mayorkun Re-United With His Dad After Two Years
Entertainment
26 views
Entertainment
26 views

Moment Nigerian Singer Mayorkun Re-United With His Dad After Two Years

MT - April 23, 2018

Singer Mayorkun has reunited with his dad in Dallas. The singer says the last time he saw his dad was two years ago when he was still…

#BBNaija Special: According to Google, Cee-C is the Most Bitter Woman in Nigeria
Buzz & Trends
25 views
Buzz & Trends
25 views

#BBNaija Special: According to Google, Cee-C is the Most Bitter Woman in Nigeria

MT - April 23, 2018

Cynthia Nwadiora popularly identified as Cee-C was tagged a very bitter and angry person following her controversial activities at the Big Brother Naija reality show which was…

How Lagos Saved N4.5bn From Non-sponsorship Of Pilgrimages
Politics
25 views
Politics
25 views

How Lagos Saved N4.5bn From Non-sponsorship Of Pilgrimages

PH - April 23, 2018

The Lagos State Government says it has saved a total of N4.5billion in the last three years since it stopped funding pilgrimages. According to it, the feat…

Afrobeat Artiste, Seun Kuti, Unveils New Album “Black Times”
Entertainment
24 views
Entertainment
24 views

Afrobeat Artiste, Seun Kuti, Unveils New Album “Black Times”

PH - April 23, 2018

Afrobeat artiste Seun Kuti has announced a new album, “Black Times“. According to him, “Black Times is a true reflection of my political and social beliefs; it…

Former Super Eagles Star, Femi Opabunmi Reveals How He Became Blind
Politics
29 views
Politics
29 views

Former Super Eagles Star, Femi Opabunmi Reveals How He Became Blind

MT - April 23, 2018

There is a photo of Femi Opabunmi trying to mark David Beckham in what look liked a set-piece situation during Nigeria’s goalless draw against England in a…

#BBNaija: See All the Prizes Miracle Will Be Going Home With After He Emerged Winner
Entertainment
32 views
Entertainment
32 views

#BBNaija: See All the Prizes Miracle Will Be Going Home With After He Emerged Winner

MT - April 23, 2018

Big Brother Naija 2018 winner, Miracle Igbokwe is still counting his blessings after winning the reality television show yesterday night. A list of all the prizes he…

Read Vimbai’s Open Letter to #BBNaija Housemates
Entertainment
29 views
Entertainment
29 views

Read Vimbai’s Open Letter to #BBNaija Housemates

PH - April 23, 2018

Former Big Brother Africa housemate and media personality, Vimbai Mutinhiri in a new post on her Instagram page, has a message for the housemates from the recently…

25-yr-old Nigerian Man Becomes Africa’s first PhD holder in National Security Strategy In The UK
Best of Nigeria
43 views
Best of Nigeria
43 views

25-yr-old Nigerian Man Becomes Africa’s first PhD holder in National Security Strategy In The UK

PH - April 23, 2018

A 25-year-old U.K based Nigerian man and Twitter @olamideDIY just achieved a great feat of becoming Africa’s first PhD holder in National Security Strategy. Sharing the amazing…

Actress Omoni Oboli Launches Feeding Outreach “Sister Lizzy’s Kitchen” in memory of Late Mum
Entertainment
29 views
Entertainment
29 views

Actress Omoni Oboli Launches Feeding Outreach “Sister Lizzy’s Kitchen” in memory of Late Mum

PH - April 23, 2018

Nollywood actress and latest author in town, Omoni Oboli, turned forty yesterday and to celebrate her new age, she spent her day with the children of Makoko…

Nigeria’s Chinedu Moghalu Appointed Head, Communications & Advocacy, Africa Risk Capacity/UN WFP
World Buzz
41 views
World Buzz
41 views

Nigeria’s Chinedu Moghalu Appointed Head, Communications & Advocacy, Africa Risk Capacity/UN WFP

PH - April 23, 2018

Chinedu Moghalu, a Nigerian, has been appointed the Senior Communications Specialist/Head, Communications & Advocacy for the Africa Risk Capacity/United Nations World Food Programme, based in Johannesburg, South…

#BBNaija’s Teddy-A Surprises BamBam on her Birthday (Photo)
Entertainment
47 views
Entertainment
47 views

#BBNaija’s Teddy-A Surprises BamBam on her Birthday (Photo)

PH - April 23, 2018

Today is Big Brother Naija’s BamBam’s birthday, and to celebrate, her one-time strategic partner in the house Teddy-A paid her a surprise. According to Olorisupergal, Teddy-A threw…

#BBNaija’s BamBam to launch Beauty Oils on her Birthday
Business
37 views
Business
37 views

#BBNaija’s BamBam to launch Beauty Oils on her Birthday

PH - April 23, 2018

Bam Beauty Oils – that’s the brand name of the beauty oil collection Big Brother Naija’s BamBam is set to launch on her birthday, April 23. BamBam…

#BBNaija’s Teddy A To Launch Clothing Line “Badman Apparel”
Entertainment
41 views
Entertainment
41 views

#BBNaija’s Teddy A To Launch Clothing Line “Badman Apparel”

PH - April 23, 2018

Hot out of the “Big Brother Naija” house, evicted housemate Teddy A is set to launch a clothing line. The musician made the announcement on his Twitter,…

Omoni Oboli Celebrates 40th Birthday With New Book
Entertainment
34 views
Entertainment
34 views

Omoni Oboli Celebrates 40th Birthday With New Book

PH - April 23, 2018

You can now add author as a title when referring to Nollywood actress Omoni Oboli who turned 40 today. To celebrate the big 4-0, the actress has…

Nigeria’s Most Bitter Woman
Entertainment
38 views
Entertainment
38 views

Nigeria’s Most Bitter Woman

PH - April 23, 2018

Who is Nigeria’s Most Bitter Woman? We asked the Google Image search engine for this question and you won’t believe what we found. But first, congratulations again…

Chude Jideonwo Covers Latest Issue of The Guardian Life Magazine
Entertainment
53 views
Entertainment
53 views

Chude Jideonwo Covers Latest Issue of The Guardian Life Magazine

PH - April 23, 2018

Joy, Inc. founder, Chude Jideonwo is on the cover of this Sunday’s edition of The Guardian Life magazine. Tagged ‘The harbinger of joy’, in the issue Chude…

Miracle Named Winner Of BBNaija 2018
Entertainment
70 views1
Entertainment
70 views1

Miracle Named Winner Of BBNaija 2018

PH - April 23, 2018

Miracle has emerged the winner of the Nigeria’s biggest reality TV show, Big Brother Naija, BBNaija which started since January 28, with 20 housemates. Miracle will be…

Loading...