14 Views

How Human Nature Is Holding Back Technology

Innovation has been resisted for centuries. From refrigeration to margarine, recorded music and, more recently, robotics and artificial intelligence, new technologies face opposition by people. In a newly released book, Professor Calestous Juma of the Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs chronicles the history of this opposition to change over 600 years. The Conversation Africa’s Samantha Spooner asked Juma about his main findings.

Your study tracks resistance to new technologies and innovations. What were the main drivers of this resistance?

The main driving force behind the cases of resistance to new technologies that I address in the book is the perception of loss. People do not oppose technologies simply because they are new or because they are ignorant. They resist loss. The loss can be in the form of income, identity, worldview or power.

The key point here is that resistance to new technologies is driven by perceptions, not actual evidence. The perception of loss can be amplified by factors such as social inequity. For example, resistance to new technologies is intensified by the perception that its benefits are likely to accrue to a small section of society while the risks could affect a wider section of society.

Similarly, the perception that new technologies could lead to immediate impacts while the benefits will be realised in the long run tends to intensify opposition. Providing scientific evidence as a way to address the opposition may intensify the resistance if it doesn’t address the underlying factors related to loss.

What form did the resistance take?

The resistance takes many forms, which include delaying adoption, seeking additional information on the risks and benefits of new technologies, or engaging in outright opposition. In cases involving outright opposition, political tactics are usually used. This often involves seeking to expand the base for opposition through recruitment campaigns. In these cases the end tends to justify the means, so it is not uncommon to see opponents rely on demonisation, misinformation, downright lies and innuendo.

Legal means have often been used to block the spread of new technologies. This takes the form of demands to prove that new products are safe. As was done in the case of margarine in the US, laws related to taxation, labelling, production and sale are introduced, but with the intent of blocking the product. There are also many examples where research facilities have been vandalised as a way to prevent the generation of information that could be used to approve new products.

Can you give examples of interactions between new technologies and African cultures?

Cultures are dynamic and co-evolve with new technologies, as has been shown in the case of mobile phones in Africa. Early concerns that mobile phones could cause cancer waned as the benefits of the technology became more evident. Today mobile phones have become part of the culture.

Transgenic crops, however, continue to be challenged across Africa, partly because of theperceived risks that they create for incumbent farming systems. Adoption of these crops is selective, reflecting the slow pace at which agricultural systems change. Other examples of tensions between technology and incumbent agriculture include opposition to the adoption ofmechanical harvesting of tea in Kenya. Another area of technological anxiety includesconflict between traditional and Uber drivers, also in Kenya.

Why is resistance to change a problem?

Resistance to innovation is a problem because it may deny society the opportunity to use new technologies to address a variety of economic, environmental and governance challenges. This is why it is important for society to have a better understanding of the sources of opposition to technology rather than rely on clichés such as “resistance is futile” or a dismissive reference to Luddites.

There is a paradox of mounting economic and ecological challenges and accelerating technological advancement. This would suggest that humanity has more opportunities to address the challenges using new technologies. However, the rate of change is now manifestly so rapid that it is creating technological anxiety. This could lead to low rates of technology adoption and general disenchantment with innovation.

There is general disquiet over emerging fields such as artificial intelligence, gene editing, robotics, drones and 3D printing. This is mainly because the potential impact of these technologies is likely to be qualitatively different from historical experiences when large sections of society had sufficient time to adjust to change.

Today machines can learn to perform certain functions faster than we retrain the affected workers. This type of scenario is largely unprecedented and technologies will need to be governed differently.

Is resistance to innovation today as strong as it was, say, 100 years ago?

The dynamics of resistance to innovation have hardly changed over the 600 years that my book covers. This is partly because human nature has not changed over that period. Even more important is the fact that uncertainty, which is a key trigger of public controversy, is only compounded by technological advancement and diversity.

What is different, however, is that the pace of advancement is manifestly rapid and that we now live in a world where the effects of new technologies are more manifest. Equally important is the fact that neoliberal ideologies have helped to create a world in which inequality is accepted and supported by business models that glorify social disruption. These developments are no good for innovation.

What innovations are being resisted today that could have a dramatic effect in addressing major global challenges such as poverty and climate change?

In the 1980s I did my graduate studies on renewable energy. My MSc thesis at the Science Policy Research Unit at Sussex was on solar photovoltaic (PV) technology. Then the cost of PV was about US$20 per kilowatt hour. Today the price is about 25 US cents. With this drop we have also seen resistance to renewable energy from the fossil fuel industry. Such opposition could compromise our ability to address climate change.

Another important area is artificial intelligence, which will affect every aspect of human life, including the manufacture of top hats and, in the near future, the generation of cartoons. Leading technologists and scientists such as Bill Gates and Martin Rees at Cambridge University are sounding their caution and urging society to reflect deeply about the implications of such technologies.

The point here is not to oppose the technology but to find a new modus vivendi that reflects contemporary times.

 

Read more here

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Latest Posts

Apostle Suleiman And Pastor Iginla Nominated For Nollywood Ambassadors Awards
Entertainment
26 views
Entertainment
26 views

Apostle Suleiman And Pastor Iginla Nominated For Nollywood Ambassadors Awards

Mabel - September 25, 2017

Apostle Johnson Suleiman and Pastor Joshua Iginla have been nominated for the maiden edition of the Nollywood Ambassadors Awards (NAA) slated to hold in Abuja on Sept. 29. President of the Nollywood…

LIST: Top 10 Terrible Loans You Should Avoid
Business
33 views
Business
33 views

LIST: Top 10 Terrible Loans You Should Avoid

MT - September 25, 2017

We’ve all been taught that most types of debt are bad news. But some loans are such egregiously awful financial instruments, we think they deserve special mention.…

Nigerian Comedian, Seyi Law And Singer, Ice Prince Receive Peace Achievers Awards
Entertainment
25 views
Entertainment
25 views

Nigerian Comedian, Seyi Law And Singer, Ice Prince Receive Peace Achievers Awards

Mabel - September 25, 2017

Nigerian singer Ice Prince and a veteran comedian Seyi Law, have been honoured with the “Peace Achievers Awards” by the Peace Ambassador Agency, an organisation that promotes national peace. The…

Photos: The Otedola’s Storm Mr Eazi’s Concert In London
Entertainment
41 views
Entertainment
41 views

Photos: The Otedola’s Storm Mr Eazi’s Concert In London

Mabel - September 25, 2017

Billionaire Daughter, Temi Otedola has been pictured with her boyfriend, Mr Eazi at his concert in London.. She was also pictured with her sister, DJ Cuppy and…

Ecobank Introduces Cardless Cash Withdrawal Service
Business
25 views
Business
25 views

Ecobank Introduces Cardless Cash Withdrawal Service

PH - September 25, 2017

Ecobank said it is striving to address the needs of the unbanked (and the general populace) by transforming a mobile phone into an all-in-one bank account and…

Why We Tagged UNILORIN, A Terrorist Organisation – ASUU Leadership
Shocking
32 views
Shocking
32 views

Why We Tagged UNILORIN, A Terrorist Organisation – ASUU Leadership

MT - September 25, 2017

The Academic Staff Union of Universities has described the University of Ilorin as a terrorist organisation after the institution reportedly sacked the ASUU chairman in the school,…

Checkout Photo Of Pastor Chris Oyakhilome And His Daughter, Sharon
Religion
39 views
Religion
39 views

Checkout Photo Of Pastor Chris Oyakhilome And His Daughter, Sharon

Mabel - September 25, 2017

Pastor Chris Oyakhilome’s Daughter, Carissa Sharon has shared an adorable picture of herself and her dad, at an event in South Africa. Sharon shared the below selfie…

Here Is Today’s Naira to Dollar Exchange Rate – September 25, 2017.
Business
35 views
Business
35 views

Here Is Today’s Naira to Dollar Exchange Rate – September 25, 2017.

MT - September 25, 2017

Here is the Current Aboki FX online AbokiFx Rate for Black Market , Bank Rates and more on Dollar to Naira. NGN USD BUY / SELL GBP BUY / SELL EUR BUY / SELL 25/09/2017 363…

Celebrity Birthday: Ex-BBNaija’s Kemen Ekemini Ekerette Celebrates His 28th Birthday With Cute Photos
Entertainment
49 views
Entertainment
49 views

Celebrity Birthday: Ex-BBNaija’s Kemen Ekemini Ekerette Celebrates His 28th Birthday With Cute Photos

MT - September 25, 2017

BBN ex-housemate, Kemen took to his Instagram handle to shares photos to make his new age today.

Photos: Former BBNaija Housemate Kemen Is A Year Older
Entertainment
33 views
Entertainment
33 views

Photos: Former BBNaija Housemate Kemen Is A Year Older

Mabel - September 25, 2017

Former Big Brother Naija housemate, Ekemini Ekerette popularly known as Kemen is celebrating his birthday today. The fitness trainer who was involved in a messy sexual assault controversy with…

This Is What Actually Happened On Olu Jacobs And Joke Silva’s Wedding Day.
Entertainment
35 views
Entertainment
35 views

This Is What Actually Happened On Olu Jacobs And Joke Silva’s Wedding Day.

MT - September 25, 2017

  Veteran actor Olu Jacobs in a recent interview has revealed some details about his wedding day. According to Uncle Olu, as he is fondly called, he…

VIDEO: Watch Tonto Dikeh React To Rumours That Her Swollen Eye Is A Spiritual Attack
Entertainment
39 views
Entertainment
39 views

VIDEO: Watch Tonto Dikeh React To Rumours That Her Swollen Eye Is A Spiritual Attack

MT - September 25, 2017

Nigerian actress and mother of one, Tonto Dikeh has come out to refute the news currently circulating by bloggers about her, being spiritually attacked in the eye.…

How I Left My Property During Biafra Civil War To Save My Life – 81-Year-old Businessman Speaks Up
Art, History and Culture
39 views
Art, History and Culture
39 views

How I Left My Property During Biafra Civil War To Save My Life – 81-Year-old Businessman Speaks Up

MT - September 25, 2017

An elderly retired businessman has opened up on how he had to flee for his dear life, abandoning his property during the Biafran war. Ikeme Alphonsus A…

Here Is Davido’s Reaction To The Lying Female Fan: “She Lied, I’m Not Even Replying DMs Anymore”
Entertainment
31 views
Entertainment
31 views

Here Is Davido’s Reaction To The Lying Female Fan: “She Lied, I’m Not Even Replying DMs Anymore”

MT - September 25, 2017

  Popular singer, Davido has made a public announcement that he won’t be replying to DMs anymore, after a lady named Sheila lied against him. The singer…

How I Survived The Controversial Lawsuit Slammed Against Me – Omoni Oboli.
Entertainment
30 views
Entertainment
30 views

How I Survived The Controversial Lawsuit Slammed Against Me – Omoni Oboli.

MT - September 25, 2017

Popular Nigerian actress, Omoni Oboli has opened up on how she managed to survive the lawsuit slammed on her after producing one of her movies. Omoni Oboli…

The Secret Behind My Happiness And Youthful Looks – Kate Henshaw Makes Interesting Revelation
Entertainment
43 views
Entertainment
43 views

The Secret Behind My Happiness And Youthful Looks – Kate Henshaw Makes Interesting Revelation

MT - September 25, 2017

Reigning Nigerian actress, Kate Henshaw, has disclosed the secrets of his good looks and youthful appearance. Kate Henshaw Even though Nigerian actress, Kate Henshaw is closer to…

In Photos: Ooni of Ife, Ogunwusi Laughs So Hard As He Attends Wedding Ceremony In Abuja
Art, History and Culture
33 views
Art, History and Culture
33 views

In Photos: Ooni of Ife, Ogunwusi Laughs So Hard As He Attends Wedding Ceremony In Abuja

MT - September 25, 2017

The paramount traditional ruler in Osun State, South-western part of Nigeria – Ooni of Ife appears to have put his marriage crisis behind him.   Ooni of…

Ooni of Ife Ex-wife, Queen Zaynab, Awarded ‘Humanitarian of the Year” Award At The UN
Best of Nigeria
51 views
Best of Nigeria
51 views

Ooni of Ife Ex-wife, Queen Zaynab, Awarded ‘Humanitarian of the Year” Award At The UN

PH - September 25, 2017

Philanthropist and former Olori of Ife Zaynab-Otiti Obanor received the Humanitarian of the Year award from “Kechie’s Project” at an event during the UN General Assembly week. She shared the…

Loading...