197 Views

Why Low-Fee Private Schools Are Struggling To Take Root In Rural Nigeria

On a walk through the slums of Nigeria’s capital city, Abuja, or its economic heartland, Lagos, you’ll learn something about the country’s education system today: low-cost private schools are everywhere.

They’re small and often occupy ramshackle buildings, but they cater for the vast majority of children in Lagos, and appear to be doing so in Abuja’s slums too. These schools far outnumber government institutions in such settlements. A Lagos or Abuja slum will usually have just one government school compound; not enough to cater for all the children in the catchment area.

This development isn’t unique to Nigeria. Low-fee private schools are on the rise in India, Pakistan, Ghana, Kenya and Uganda. Even when a government provides free universal primary education, many parents will still choose to pay because they believe private schooling gives their children a better chance for learning – or because the government school is just too far to walk to.

Nigerians in cities have some choices about where to school their children. But what about their counterparts in the country’s expansive rural areas? Research I’ve conducted finds that it’s very rare for children in rural areas to have any access to private schooling. Instead they are forced to rely on poor quality, poorly resourced government schools.

What’s happening in Kwara State

Nigeria’s population was estimated at more than 182 million in 2015. Its rural population accounts for just over half.

I conducted a study for the UK Department for International Development’s Education Sector Support Programme in Nigeria while living in Ilorin, the capital of Kwara State. Kwara is one of Nigeria’s poorest and least-known states. It doesn’t enjoy the same prosperity as the south-west yet neither does it struggle with intractable problems such as those of the north-east or the Niger Delta.

With a team of fieldworkers I set out to find out how many private schools had popped up in Ilorin, the state’s largest urban centre, focusing on and reaching every part of Ilorin West Local Government Area. We wanted to contrast this with what we would find in Kwara’s remote rural areas, choosing Baruten in the state’s north-west and Ifelodun in the south-east. To do so, we walked through town to reach the most hidden corners, and drove long distances in the country, exploring all the villages we could find.

The condition of Kwara’s government education system was abysmal at the start of our work in the state. An assessment conducted in 2008, three years before our fieldwork, found that fewer than half of one percentage point of the state’s teachers could pass a test of primary grade 4 level material.

Some parents have been increasingly responding to this low quality by pulling their children out of government education in favour of relatively low-fee private schools. This was especially true in urban Ilorin. But there were barely any low-fee private schools in the rural areas we studied.

Hardly any market

There are far more low-fee private schools in Kwara State’s urban centres than in its rural areas. Supplied

We found 294 low-fee private schools in urban Ilorin. Only a third of these were known to the government’s Ministry of Education.

The situation was very different in the rural areas. We drove for endless kilometres on unbelievably rough roads with no form of public transportation, from remote village to remote village. In Baruten and Ifelodun combined we found about a third of the number we’d located in just one large part of Ilorin.

ALSO READ  15 Rare Photos Of Former President, Olusegun Obasanjo

In most villages people didn’t even know what a private school was. They usually simply directed us to the only village school: that provided by the government.

In the same year, Nigeria carried out a nationally representative household survey with the support of USAID. It found that just 9.3% of all rural children were attending private schools in Kwara State. The figure was 58% for urban children. Starker still: 1.5% of those children who fall in the poorest 40% of Kwara’s population were attending private school. The figure was 80% among the richest 20% of children.

Neither my study’s findings nor those of the representative household survey are surprising. There is simply virtually no market for private schooling in remote rural areas of this Nigerian state.

Why is this the case?

Geography and poverty

Part of the reason is geographical. Kwara is sparsely populated. At the time of our study there were just 80 people per square kilometre. Contrast that with another area that I’ve studied, rural western Uttar Pradesh in India. This had 820 people per square kilometre at about the same time and many private schools alongside those run by the government.

Low-fee private schools are essentially businesses. They need to cover their costs: teachers’ salaries, basic materials and infrastructure, and a salary for the head of the school who is usually also the proprietor. So if there are relatively few children in a village and some are going to government school – which are relatively plentiful in these rural areas – then in most places there are simply too few children to support a private school’s existence. There are often too few children to support the existence of more than one of any type of school.

The second and biggest reason for the lack of growth in Kwara’s private schooling landscape is poverty.

A poor child in Kwara is lucky to go to school at all. The household survey showed that two-thirds of ten- to 16-year-olds in the poorest 40% had never been enrolled in any school. The indications are that fee-paying options are no solution for the very poor. And there is therefore no market logic for private operators.

Where to improve the system

So how can the absence of access to quality education for rural Nigerians be addressed?

The most equitable action would involve fixing government schools – while at the same time leaving existing private schools to just get on with what they are doing. The government needs to concentrate its resources on reaching the poor and remote. Quality simply must be improved to make accessing government schools appear worthwhile.

There are aspects of private school management, staffing and teaching methods that currently failing government systems could usefully adopt.

These include, wherever possible, hiring local people who are part of the community. They’ll have a greater understanding of their neighbours, and be more accountable. They’ll also be used to living in tough rural conditions and won’t miss classes because they’re relying on public transport from elsewhere.

If they are not so knowledgeable, and maybe not qualified teachers (just like existing government teachers), these people can be supported with extensive materials to boost their teaching. The Education Sector Support Programme in Nigeria has already drawn on this approach in its work with government school teachers by developing set lesson plans for all teachers to use. On-paper qualifications should not be everything: many of Kwara’s failing teachers tested in 2008 were formally qualified.

 

Source: The Conversation

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Latest Posts

Nigeria To Grow By 2.1% This Year – IMF
Business
12 views
Business
12 views

Nigeria To Grow By 2.1% This Year – IMF

PH - April 19, 2018

The International Monetary Fund says Nigeria, the sub-Saharan Africa’s most-populous nation and top crude producer, will grow by 2.1 per cent this year, matching the lender’s estimate…

Bodex Media Awards Governor Aregbesola as the Most Outstanding/Creative Governor of the Year 2018
Best of Nigeria
18 views
Best of Nigeria
18 views

Bodex Media Awards Governor Aregbesola as the Most Outstanding/Creative Governor of the Year 2018

PH - April 19, 2018

The Governor of Osun state, Ogbeni Rauf Aregbesola has been honoured with an award of the most outstanding and creative Governor of the Year, 2018. The Award…

‘I Was Molested At 17 By A Big Man In Media’ – Chimamanda Adichie
Nigerian Women
23 views
Nigerian Women
23 views

‘I Was Molested At 17 By A Big Man In Media’ – Chimamanda Adichie

PH - April 19, 2018

Celebrated Nigerian author, Chimamanda Adichie, who spoke at the Stockholm Forum for Gender Equality, revealed that she was molested at the age of 17. Chimamanda Adichie told…

I Communicate More With God When I’m in the Bathroom – Actress, Funke Adesiyan
Entertainment
63 views
Entertainment
63 views

I Communicate More With God When I’m in the Bathroom – Actress, Funke Adesiyan

MT - April 18, 2018

Funke Adesiyan, has not stopped making headlines each week with some of the controversial things she says or involved in a fight with a fan, but she…

Photos And Video Of Senator Ovie Omo-Agege Being Arrested By The Police For Snatching Mace (Video)
Politics
56 views
Politics
56 views

Photos And Video Of Senator Ovie Omo-Agege Being Arrested By The Police For Snatching Mace (Video)

MT - April 18, 2018

The senator representing Delta Central in the Senate, Ovie Omo-Agege was today arrested by the police after he allegedly led thugs to steal the mace at the…

Flashback to 2000: How Policemen Invaded Okadigbo’s Residence to Retrieve Senate’s Mace
Art, History and Culture
64 views
Art, History and Culture
64 views

Flashback to 2000: How Policemen Invaded Okadigbo’s Residence to Retrieve Senate’s Mace

MT - April 18, 2018

There is nothing new under the sun. On Wednesday, Ovie Omo-Agege, a senator from Delta state, led some unidentified persons into the upper legislative chamber of the…

Kano N1.2 Billion Longest Underpass Ready For Use (Video)
Best of Nigeria
70 views
Best of Nigeria
70 views

Kano N1.2 Billion Longest Underpass Ready For Use (Video)

MT - April 18, 2018

Kano state government construct the vehicle underpass at cost of N1.2 billion, at the busy Bukavu Barrack junction adjoining Kofar Ruwa, along Katsina road – Aminu Kano…

Meet Suashi Emmanuella Ini-Usoro, The Managing Partner Of Ebusiness Hub Nigeria In An Interview With #StarsConnect
Business
62 views
Business
62 views

Meet Suashi Emmanuella Ini-Usoro, The Managing Partner Of Ebusiness Hub Nigeria In An Interview With #StarsConnect

PH - April 18, 2018

Ebusiness Technology solutions Hub, popularly known as Ebusiness Hub Nigeria provides Digital support, Social media and ecommerce management services for MSMEs. And today, we have the managing…

DJ Cuppy’s “Green Light” hits 1 Million Streams on Spotify
Entertainment
52 views
Entertainment
52 views

DJ Cuppy’s “Green Light” hits 1 Million Streams on Spotify

PH - April 18, 2018

It’s been a good year so far for DJ Cuppy, from being announced as a Pepsi Brand ambassador to her sophmore single Vybe featuring Sarkodie doing well…

Seyi Shay and Bovi Unveiled as Hosts for the 12th Headies Awards
Entertainment
48 views
Entertainment
48 views

Seyi Shay and Bovi Unveiled as Hosts for the 12th Headies Awards

PH - April 18, 2018

The 12th edition of the annual Headies award show is right around the corner. Award winning musician Seyi Shay and comedian Bovi have just been announced as…

Senator Shehu Sani Reveals What He Did After Senate’s Mace Was Stolen
Politics
82 views
Politics
82 views

Senator Shehu Sani Reveals What He Did After Senate’s Mace Was Stolen

PH - April 18, 2018

Senator Shehu Sani representing Kaduna Central, has reacted to the snatching of the Senate mace from the upper legislative chambers. According to the senator, while the senate…

How Senator Omo-Agege And ‘Thugs’ Ran Way With Senate’s Mace
Politics
58 views
Politics
58 views

How Senator Omo-Agege And ‘Thugs’ Ran Way With Senate’s Mace

PH - April 18, 2018

In what came as a surprise on Wednesday, Ovie Omo-Agege, a senator from Delta state, invaded the national assembly with suspected thugs who seized the mace. Omo-Agege,…

Nollywood Stars Iyke and Florence Okechukwu Celebrate 5th Wedding Anniversary
Entertainment
72 views
Entertainment
72 views

Nollywood Stars Iyke and Florence Okechukwu Celebrate 5th Wedding Anniversary

PH - April 18, 2018

Nollywood stars Iyke and Florence Okechukwu, popularly known for their roles in Tinsel as Chuks and Ene, are celebrating their 5th wedding anniversary today. Iyke took to…

Nigerian Model, Mayowa Nicholas, Featured In American Vogue’s May 2018 Issue
Entertainment
60 views
Entertainment
60 views

Nigerian Model, Mayowa Nicholas, Featured In American Vogue’s May 2018 Issue

PH - April 18, 2018

From the runways in Milan to full spread Billboard features in New York, our girl Mayowa Nicholas is having a great year! Although she missed a spot…

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie Wins ‘Best in Literature’ at 10th Annual Shorty Awards in New York
Best of Nigeria
57 views
Best of Nigeria
57 views

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie Wins ‘Best in Literature’ at 10th Annual Shorty Awards in New York

PH - April 18, 2018

The Shorty Awards honor the best content creators and producers on social media: Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Tumblr, Instagram, Snapchat and the rest of the digital world. The…

WATCH out For EbonyLife and Niyi Akinmolayan’s New film “Chief Daddy”
Entertainment
49 views
Entertainment
49 views

WATCH out For EbonyLife and Niyi Akinmolayan’s New film “Chief Daddy”

PH - April 18, 2018

What happens when you take the best of Nollywood you can find and sprinkle in a few new faces, who are genius at their craft? An epic…

Onyeka Nwelue’s New Film Feature “Wole Soyinka: A God and the Biafrans” to be Previewed at Harvard University
Entertainment
90 views
Entertainment
90 views

Onyeka Nwelue’s New Film Feature “Wole Soyinka: A God and the Biafrans” to be Previewed at Harvard University

PH - April 18, 2018

Award-winning Nigerian writer and filmmaker, Onyeka Nwelue is at Harvard University, working at The Cooper Gallery, Hutchins Center for African & African American Research, developing and curating…

Nigerian Singer, Ajebutter22’s “Ghana Bounce” Hits 1 Million Streams On Spotify
Entertainment
58 views
Entertainment
58 views

Nigerian Singer, Ajebutter22’s “Ghana Bounce” Hits 1 Million Streams On Spotify

PH - April 18, 2018

Nigerian singer Ajebutter22 had a pretty good outing last year courtesy of hit songs like Wayward & Ghana Bounce, also dropping his album What Happens In Lagos.…

Loading...