97 Views

How MTN Succeeded In Reducing A $3.9 Billion Fine Imposed In Nigeria

Telecoms firm MTN hired former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder in January to help it reduce a $3.9 billion fine imposed in Nigeria over unregistered SIM cards. Five months later, it struck a deal to pay less than half of that.
The entrance of Holder, who stood down as attorney general last year after presiding over some of the largest corporate settlements in American history, marked a change of strategy for the South African company.
MTN dropped a three-month legal challenge against the fine and, according to government sources and letters seen by Reuters, asked Nigerian Attorney General Abubakar Malami to put forward a proposal for a reduced fine to the communications regulator, the official authority in the dispute.
The regulator, the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC), rejected the proposal as unjustifiable, documents show, but three months later it accepted a broadly similar deal. Reuters was unable to determine the role, if any, that Holder played in the change of heart.
MTN, Holder, Malami and the NCC all declined to comment on the negotiation process.
There is no indication that any individuals acted improperly, and companies have often reached settlements with regulators in Nigeria. Lawmakers have however criticised the opaque nature of the settlement process, saying it set a precedent for other firms dealing with Nigerian authorities.
The 780 billion naira fine – $3.9 billion at the exchange rate at the time – was set by the NCC in December over MTN’s failure to deactivate more than 5 million SIM cards not registered by customers. Nigeria has been trying to halt the use of unregistered cards over concerns they are being used for criminal activity, including by Islamist militant group Boko Haram.
MTN, Africa’s biggest telecoms company, initially launched a high court challenge against the fine, arguing the watchdog had no legal grounds to order it. The law states that the NCC does have the right to impose such a penalty.
In February, however, MTN withdrew the lawsuit and paid a “good faith” payment of 50 billion naira to the government which it said was part of efforts to reach an amicable settlement and would go towards the eventual fine agreed.
The NCC said at the time that it had not agreed to enter into any talks with MTN and that it stood by the 780 billion naira penalty.
Rather than dealing directly with the regulator, Holder approached Malami to help broker a settlement, according to the government sources and letters seen by Reuters.
LETTERS
In a letter dated the same day MTN announced it was dropping its court challenge – Feb. 24 – Holder wrote to Malami on behalf of the company offering to pay 300 billion naira and list MTN’s local unit on the Nigerian stock exchange to end the dispute.
Under the Nigerian constitution, the attorney general can mediate in a dispute involving a state body after the matter has been taken to court.
Malami asked NCC to review the MTN offer but the regulator was not impressed, according to another letter seen by Reuters.
“The proposal to pay the sum of 300 billion naira … is not supported by any verifiable justification,” NCC Chief Executive Umar Garba Danbatta said in a March 1 letter to Malami.
Nor was the NCC convinced by MTN’s sweetener of a local listing. “This is a business decision absolutely within MTN’s prerogative and primarily to its benefit. There is no justification for bringing this along in discussing the present issue,” Danbatta said.
But when MTN announced on June 10 that it reached a deal with the government to pay a fine of 330 billion naira – just 30 billion naira more – the NCC appeared to have altered its view, notifying parliament in a letter dated the same day of a “full and final” settlement.
“It was never about the money it was about making clear the rules are the rules,” NCC spokesman Tony Ojobo told Reuters on June 13. “The MTN listing is a big positive for Nigeria and will benefit the country.”
When asked about the March 1 letter and what had changed the NCC’s view, Ojobo said he would not discuss the negotiations.
A parliamentary committee on telecommunications is reviewing the deal and the negotiations that led to it. Such reviews by lawmakers are standard practice after big corporate settlements and are aimed at ensuring that there has been no wrongdoing by any party involved and that the public interest has been served.
“What concerns us most is what MTN proposes in February is so similar to what is agreed in June. It is clear MTN were dictating the pace,” committee chairman Saheed Akinade-Fijabi told Reuters.
“What does this say to other businesses? That to get the best deal you use unofficial back channels and keep the public in the dark?”
DIVISIONS
The deal has exposed divisions within the Nigerian government; officials within President Muhammadu Buhari’s team were also unhappy with Malami’s plans to strike a deal with MTN which they considered too generous, leading to heated discussions between the two camps, two government sources said.
There has been no official comment from Buhari on the settlement.
Holder was hired by MTN through his Washington-based law firm Covington and Burling which he joined last year after six years as U.S. attorney general.
Settlements he presided over in public office included the $13 billion JPMorgan Chase paid to settle charges of mis-selling mortgages in the run-up to the financial crisis and the BP Deepwater Horizon oil spill case, which has topped $20 billion.
It is unclear whether Holder has been based in Nigeria during his time working for MTN, which counts Nigeria as its biggest market. It also is unclear whether he still advises MTN. Covington and Burling declined to comment.
Following the settlement MTN’s share price, which had fallen around 30 percent between a fine being announced and Holder being hired, has risen by around 25 percent. (Additional reporting by Tiisetso Motsoeneng in Johannesburg, Felix Onuah and Camillus Eboh in Abuja; Editing by Pravin Char)
Reuters

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Latest Posts

Wizkid’s First Son, Boluwatife Balogun Swags Up In News Photos
Entertainment
45 views
Entertainment
45 views

Wizkid’s First Son, Boluwatife Balogun Swags Up In News Photos

MT - January 19, 2018

When your father is Wizkid Ayo Balogun, then swag is expected! Shola Ogudu, Wizkid's first baby mama shared these lovely new photos of their son, Boluwatife. 

“Doctor Saves Life In Theatre, You Take Gifts To Pastors” – Daddy Freeze, Crazeclown
Entertainment
50 views
Entertainment
50 views

“Doctor Saves Life In Theatre, You Take Gifts To Pastors” – Daddy Freeze, Crazeclown

MT - January 19, 2018

Is It Right? Doctors Spent Hours To Save Your Life In Theatre, You Take Your Gifts To Pastors - Freeze Daddy Freeze don start again today oo,…

Actress Rukky Sanda Steps Out In Ripped Jeans And People Are Talking About It (Photos)
Entertainment
36 views
Entertainment
36 views

Actress Rukky Sanda Steps Out In Ripped Jeans And People Are Talking About It (Photos)

MT - January 19, 2018

The actress and single 33yr old has been off from the movie screen lately, but she seems to be doing just fine judging by her photos, It…

7 Foods That Will Boost Your Digestive Health
Food and Health
34 views
Food and Health
34 views

7 Foods That Will Boost Your Digestive Health

MT - January 19, 2018

Your digestive system affects the well-being of every cell in your bodies. A healthy digestion will contribute to boosted energy levels, beautiful skin and rejuvenating sleep. So,…

Seyi Shay Shares Her Early Morning Photos Without Makeup (Photos)
Entertainment
49 views
Entertainment
49 views

Seyi Shay Shares Her Early Morning Photos Without Makeup (Photos)

MT - January 19, 2018

Nigerian female artiste stage named seyi shay shares her make-up free picture. She is looking cool anyway. See photos below

House Of Rep Member, Aishatu Dukku Says Herdsmen Values Lives Of His Cattle More Than Their Life
Politics
33 views
Politics
33 views

House Of Rep Member, Aishatu Dukku Says Herdsmen Values Lives Of His Cattle More Than Their Life

MT - January 19, 2018

A video making the rounds on the internet has shown a member of the House of Representatives claiming the Fulani herdsmen values his cattle more than his…

Babymama Gang: Popular Video Vixen, Beverly Osu Announces Her Pregnancy By Flaunting Baby Bump On IG
Entertainment
37 views
Entertainment
37 views

Babymama Gang: Popular Video Vixen, Beverly Osu Announces Her Pregnancy By Flaunting Baby Bump On IG

MT - January 19, 2018

It seems beautiful video vixen has join the list of baby mamas as she happily flaunt her baby bump on her instagram page, although the father of…

How A Young Nigerian Businessman Slumped And Died Hours After Mourning The Death Of His Friend
Shocking
30 views
Shocking
30 views

How A Young Nigerian Businessman Slumped And Died Hours After Mourning The Death Of His Friend

MT - January 19, 2018

A young Nigerian man based in the United States has just been reported dead after he was reported to have slumped and died just hours after losing…

DJ Cuppy Got More Than She Bargain For When She Tweeted About Recording A New Song
Entertainment
35 views
Entertainment
35 views

DJ Cuppy Got More Than She Bargain For When She Tweeted About Recording A New Song

MT - January 19, 2018

Nigerians on twitter are all sorts of savage and hilarious. After Dj Cuppy tweeted, Quote 'My throat is killing me, and I’m meant to be recording my…

Here Is How Rivers Indigenes Protested Against SARS Operation In The State (Photos)
Shocking
33 views
Shocking
33 views

Here Is How Rivers Indigenes Protested Against SARS Operation In The State (Photos)

MT - January 19, 2018

Residents of Rivers state today staged a protest calling for the disbandment of SARS operations in the state. The residents accuse officials of the State Anti-Robbery Squad…

Checkout New Photos Of Former Miss Anambra “Cucumber”, Chidinma Okeke (Photos)
Entertainment
41 views
Entertainment
41 views

Checkout New Photos Of Former Miss Anambra “Cucumber”, Chidinma Okeke (Photos)

MT - January 19, 2018

Never you be a victim of your own circumstance … The “future is now” The former beauty queen dropped one of the pictures and wrote: Quote “Go confidently…

Why Chelsea FC Could Be Banned For Two Transfer Windows By FIFA
Sports
35 views
Sports
35 views

Why Chelsea FC Could Be Banned For Two Transfer Windows By FIFA

MT - January 19, 2018

English Premier League Champions, Chelsea FC could be banned for two transfer windows as FIFA investigate the club for irregular signings, according to The Guardian. The club…

Fulani Killings: Why The Benue Crisis May Get Out Of Control – Sultan Of Sokoto Warns
Shocking
43 views
Shocking
43 views

Fulani Killings: Why The Benue Crisis May Get Out Of Control – Sultan Of Sokoto Warns

MT - January 19, 2018

Saad Abubakar, the Sultan of Sokoto, has queried the competence of the security agencies and their inability to stop the attacks and killings by herdsmen in Benue State.…

My Side Chick And My Personal Ashewo – IK Ogbonna Writes Sweet Message To His Wife On Her Birthday
Entertainment
44 views
Entertainment
44 views

My Side Chick And My Personal Ashewo – IK Ogbonna Writes Sweet Message To His Wife On Her Birthday

MT - January 19, 2018

Nollywood superstar actor, Ik Ogbonna has celebrated his wife in a unique manner by chosing to call her his side chick and ashewo in a post he…

This Plus Size Man and Fiance Spice Up Their Pre Wedding Photos With Raunchy Display
Romance and Love
43 views
Romance and Love
43 views

This Plus Size Man and Fiance Spice Up Their Pre Wedding Photos With Raunchy Display

MT - January 19, 2018

This fun-loving couple have got themselves trending online after sharing their lovely pre-wedding photos. The pair identified as Prince Biggs and Sugar Girl decided to spice up…

Meet Nigeria’s First Female Combatant Pilots In History Since 1960 Independence (Photos)
Best of Nigeria
46 views
Best of Nigeria
46 views

Meet Nigeria’s First Female Combatant Pilots In History Since 1960 Independence (Photos)

MT - January 19, 2018

The Nigerian Air Force (NAF) has disclosed on Wednesday, January 17, 2017, during commissioning of 11 young pilots that the two female combatants among the pilots are…

Meet The Governorship Aspirant “Melting The Hearts” Of Online Users (Photos)
Politics
36 views
Politics
36 views

Meet The Governorship Aspirant “Melting The Hearts” Of Online Users (Photos)

MT - January 19, 2018

The 2019 general elections will be apparently be great. A governorship aspirant, comrade Sani Garba Gusau has become an online sensation after melting hearts of online users…

Super Falcon Star, Asisat Also Stops By At Peter Okoye’s Mansion In Lagos After Visiting Paul Okoye
Entertainment
44 views
Entertainment
44 views

Super Falcon Star, Asisat Also Stops By At Peter Okoye’s Mansion In Lagos After Visiting Paul Okoye

MT - January 19, 2018

Earlier today, Super Falcon star and female African Player of the Year, Asisat Oshoala alongside Onome Ebi paid a visit to Paul Okoye aka Rude Boy at…

Loading...